Treat vs MyFitnessPal — Honest Comparison (2026)

MyFitnessPal is the most popular calorie tracker in the world, with over 200 million users. Treat is a newer AI-powered alternative focused on voice input. Here's an honest comparison of both apps to help you decide which fits your needs.

Quick Comparison

Where Treat Wins

Speed of Logging

Treat's core advantage is speed. Say "chicken stir fry with rice" and it's logged in about 10 seconds. In MyFitnessPal, you'd search "chicken stir fry," scroll through dozens of results with different calorie counts, pick one, adjust the serving size, then repeat for rice. That's 3-5 minutes per meal.

Voice Input Included in Every Plan

MyFitnessPal added voice logging, but it's locked behind their Premium subscription at $19.99/month. Treat includes voice input in every plan — even during the free trial.

Simplicity

MyFitnessPal has accumulated a lot of features over its 20-year history: community forums, blog posts, recipe databases, meal plans, exercise libraries, social feeds. If you want all that, great. If you just want to track what you eat quickly, Treat is more focused and less overwhelming.

Price

For comparable AI/voice features, Treat is half the price of MyFitnessPal Premium ($9.99/mo vs $19.99/mo). MyFitnessPal does offer a free tier, but it lacks voice logging, AI features, and many insights.

Where MyFitnessPal Wins

Food Database Size

MyFitnessPal has over 14 million verified food entries. If you eat a lot of packaged foods and want exact nutrition from labels, their database is hard to beat. Treat's AI is accurate for most meals but doesn't match barcode-level precision for specific packaged products.

Barcode Scanning

Treat doesn't have barcode scanning. If you regularly eat packaged foods with barcodes, MyFitnessPal's scanner is a genuine convenience that Treat doesn't replicate.

Platform Support

MyFitnessPal is available on iOS, Android, and the web. Treat is iOS-only. If you use Android or want to log from your computer, MyFitnessPal is the better choice right now.

Social Features & Community

MyFitnessPal has friends lists, community forums, and shared progress. Treat has no social features. If accountability through friends or community matters to you, MyFitnessPal delivers that.

Recipe Import & Meal Planning

MyFitnessPal Premium can import recipes from URLs and calculate nutrition per serving. Treat doesn't offer this — you'd describe the meal by voice instead, which is fast but less precise for complex home recipes.

Who Should Use Which

Choose Treat if:

• You want the fastest possible way to log meals
• You eat out frequently or eat varied, non-packaged meals
• You've tried calorie tracking before and quit because it was too tedious
• You want AI-powered tracking without paying $19.99/month
• You use an iPhone and want a focused, simple app

Choose MyFitnessPal if:

• You eat a lot of packaged foods and want barcode scanning
• You need Android or web access
• You want social features and community accountability
• You need recipe import and meal planning
• You prefer a free tier with basic features over a paid trial

Frequently Asked Questions